Granite and Tumble’s Top 25 Compared To Other’s

Out of curiosity, I compared my top 25 albums of 2016 with some of the other popular lists to see how much overlap existed.   More overlap this year than any other with Pinegrove leading the way appearing on 7 other lists. My greatest overlap was four with the 45 from Brooklyn Vegan. This is still relatively small as most of these lists have significant overlap. As an example, Pitchfork and Spin share 36 of the same 50 with many in the same order.

  • One overlap with the 50 from Pitchfork (Pinegrove #46)
  • Three overlaps with the 50 from Spin (Pinegrove #48 , The Hotelier #31, and Joyce Manor #23)
  • Three overlaps with the 50 from Consequence of Sound (The Hotelier #43, Into It. Over It. #35, and Pinegrove #30)
  • Two overlaps with the 50 from Paste (Andrew Bird #24 and Pinegrove #14)
  • One overlap with the 50 from NPR (Pinegrove #38)
  • One overlap with the 15 from Jon Caramanica from the NY Times (Joyce Manor #11)
  • Two overlaps with the 50 from Stereogum (The Hotelier #39 and Pinegrove #24)
  • No overlaps with the 60 from GorillavsBear
  • Four overlaps with the 45 from Brooklyn Vegan (American Football #40, The Hotelier #22, Pinegrove #10, and Joyce Manor #6)
  • And 6 overlaps with the 20 best emo/punk albums from Brooklyn Vegan (John K Samson #20, Jeff Rosenstock #12, Into it. Over It #8, American Football #5, The Hotelier #3, and Joyce Manor #1)
  • Three overlaps with the 20 from Punknews (Joyce Manor #13, John K Samson #13, and Jeff Rosenstock #8)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *